Guest viewing is limited

Welcome To The HFBM Boards
Hockey, Football, Baseball & MMA

Status
Not open for further replies.
A

archived

Prospect
LEGEND
Moola
0
What was with Saban and his his "I'm not sure what I wanna do here" coach's challenge last night? An NFL head coach needs to make that decision on a dime..
Up to that point they were still in the game but it was all downhill after that..
 
Yeah, I don't know what happened there.

Poor coaching and stupid mistakes on defense doomed the Dolphins in that game - there's no way the Steelers offense should have scored 21 points against the Dolphins defense with Batch as the QB.
 
Creeping-Cruds said:
What was with Saban and his his "I'm not sure what I wanna do here" coach's challenge last night? An NFL head coach needs to make that decision on a dime..
Up to that point they were still in the game but it was all downhill after that..
Click to expand...


I heard this morning on ESPN that he was waiting for the replay to happen on the big screen and it never came. I believe he was waiting on someone watching the replay on t.v to tell him to challenge it or not and by the time he got the word the Steelers was ready to kick the FG. Does anybody think they should bring back the buzzer?
 
MissouriTitan1 said:
I heard this morning on ESPN that he was waiting for the replay to happen on the big screen and it never came. I believe he was waiting on someone watching the replay on t.v to tell him to challenge it or not and by the time he got the word the Steelers was ready to kick the FG. Does anybody think they should bring back the buzzer?
Click to expand...

brink back the buzzer!

or

Tie the red flag to a brick and allow the coach to throw the brick at the refs- that should get their attention!
 
I thought the buzzer was still in use? Anyways, I didn't see the play, but how could Saban not get a hold of the sideline judge?
 
Vigsted said:
I thought the buzzer was still in use? Anyways, I didn't see the play, but how could Saban not get a hold of the sideline judge?
Click to expand...

The buzzer was deemed useless, as it was proven to be too unreliable. It was voted out this past offseason. It was voted in that you could run up or down the sideline, or even onto the field to throw the red hanky.

Credit Saban for NOT knowing the rule.

I would have run onto the field, wound up, and stepped into a heave, aiming at the zebra's noggin.
 
Louisiana Titan said:
brink back the buzzer!

or
Click to expand...

Give the "reviewing" team until just prior to kicking off to review the play.

Everything happens faster during an attempted PAT. And, it seems you don't have the same amount of time to review a (much more important) play.

Just a thought.
 
moose4now said:
Give the "reviewing" team until just prior to kicking off to review the play.
Click to expand...

No way. Thats part of the strategy of the game. A lot of times after a questionable call you see the other team hurry to get the next play off so it cant be reviewed. You gotta move quick if you want to challenge.
 
Crash Override said:
Regardless, they would have scored anyway.
Click to expand...

Batch had just fumbled the ball away at the exact same spot.. Maybe they only get three..
Either way credit the loss to Saban (and Culpepper's horrid passing)
 
Saban as well as a few other coaches and players were on the field after he threw the red flag. He threw the flag well before the snap and one of the officials should have seen it. I guess next time he will learn to run up to the ref and throw it in his face. Saban got shafted there... I was really pullin for the Dolphins, too. Put that Steeler SB win behind us with an 0-1 for the squeelers. :grrhee:
 
Creeping-Cruds said:
Batch had just fumbled the ball away at the exact same spot.. Maybe they only get three..
Either way credit the loss to Saban (and Culpepper's horrid passing)
Click to expand...

More likely they run a more vanilla up the gut run maybe it takes them 3 plays to get it done and they run the clock out or to almost nothing. Him not getting it gave them a chance IMO.
 
Saban has got to be more decisive - he even did a double take, started to toss it once and pulled it back, and then tossed it like he was tossing a quarter in a fountain. If you're going to wait to the last second to challenge at least get near a ref and/or do something to draw some attention.

It reminds me of the team that waited until a split second before the bal was hiked for a game winning field goal attempt - and trying to call a timeout right before the snap so the guy would go ahead with the kick it and then have to rekick it. Cutting it too close imho.
 
I think he was trying to decide if it was worth it. There was a good chance they would score and run out the clock even more. I think it was one of those damn if you do damn if you don't choices
 
He was waiting for the "go-ahead" from someone watching the replay. No coach wants to waste a timeout or review something that has no chance to be overturned.

If the TV cameras caught him throwing the flag, one of the MANY refs should have seen it. I think it was a case of no one stepping up. One of the refs saw it, the kick went off and then no one 'fessed up. As soon as one of the refs saw him walking with the red flag in his hand, he should have held up his hand and put the whistle in his mouth.

Or maybe J. Porter was giving out kisses to the refs as well.
 
elfinmagic53 said:
If the TV cameras caught him throwing the flag, one of the MANY refs should have seen it.
/QUOTE]

There are 7 officials, none of them have "constantly watch coaches to see if they are going to throw the flag" as their responsibility. Just like there isn't a dedicated "timeout watching" official.
Click to expand...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top