You could put a baked potato in at QB for that system and still get the same results.
Purdy looks the part of an NFL QB. Can he sustain that? Idk...
Willis looks like he's never heard of football.
Can he be an NFL QB? Absolutely not.
Willis looks like he's never heard of football.
Can he be an NFL QB? Absolutely not.
Willis was drafted as a project or if he wasn't then JROB was worse than I thought at evaluating talent. He should have been the 3rd string qb and not seen the field, but the Titans forced him on the field waaaaaayyyy to early and it showed in a bad way.
The NFL really should allow 3 QBs on the roster with the 3rd guy only being able to play if the other 2 get hurt in game. Would make for a better product on the field and possibly lead to better QB development.
Regarding Purdy I think he will earn the starting job for the 49ers next yr. The question is what are they going to do with Trey Lance. Do they just keep him to back up Purdy or are they willing to trade him?
We are interviewing a 49er gm.... if he becomes our GM then he will have knowledge on both Lance and Garapolo... if we are looking to go a different direction at QB.
The NFL really should allow 3 QBs on the roster with the 3rd guy only being able to play if the other 2 get hurt in game. Would make for a better product on the field and possibly lead to better QB development.
Regarding Purdy I think he will earn the starting job for the 49ers next yr. The question is what are they going to do with Trey Lance. Do they just keep him to back up Purdy or are they willing to trade him?
We are interviewing a 49er gm.... if he becomes our GM then he will have knowledge on both Lance and Garapolo... if we are looking to go a different direction at QB.
Problem is, you don’t draft projects in the 3rd round
Purdy has the “it” factor. He is confident, decisive and in control. Willis is done. Question is- should Titans make a move for Garrapolo or lance. Both are updating their resumes right now.
Pretty crazy that Jimmy G was their guy, then they decided to go with Lance (until they had to go back with Jimmy) and now they may move on from Lance already for Purdy.
But nah, Jimmy doesn't seem like an upgrade and Lance hasn't shown much in his short time either.
The best thing that can be done for a rookie QB is to allow them to play pressure free or as close to that as possible.
Purdy doesn’t NEED to do anything and SF is very much in a game, probably still favorites against most of the league.
The weapons he has without any real pressure on him is a huge bonus.
CMC does t get the credit he deserves for easily being the equal to Henry from the backfield and a big Receiving upgrade.
Willis unfortunately was also put in a position where he HAD to play well to get wins and without the same weapons or an OC that even knows how to call a game to the weapons.
As far as their draft status, I think it easy to say anything in hindsight, but every single team didn’t want Purdy at least 6x over and Willis was argued even earlier than he went. Maybe not everyone, but some.
Even our own resident GM didn’t call Purdy and he knows literally everything and is never wrong about draft picks.
Purdy doesn’t NEED to do anything and SF is very much in a game, probably still favorites against most of the league.
The weapons he has without any real pressure on him is a huge bonus.
CMC does t get the credit he deserves for easily being the equal to Henry from the backfield and a big Receiving upgrade.
Willis unfortunately was also put in a position where he HAD to play well to get wins and without the same weapons or an OC that even knows how to call a game to the weapons.
As far as their draft status, I think it easy to say anything in hindsight, but every single team didn’t want Purdy at least 6x over and Willis was argued even earlier than he went. Maybe not everyone, but some.
Even our own resident GM didn’t call Purdy and he knows literally everything and is never wrong about draft picks.
Purdy being in the right system and having competent coaches definitely helps! Willis is a big project I’m not sure the Titans have the coaching staff to help him progress
Letting an unsigned career backup start your last game in a “win and in” scenario should tell you everything you need to know about Malik Willis
And he played 10x better than Willis has in any game. So it was the right choice.
Purdy looks 10x better than Willis. And to think, some were picking Willis to go in the first round.
We’ll see what happens with his development over this next offseason with hopefully a much more competent OC and staff. But I’m doubtful that he’ll ever even be a dependable backup.
We’ll see what happens with his development over this next offseason with hopefully a much more competent OC and staff. But I’m doubtful that he’ll ever even be a dependable backup.
Precisely what I said!
until mw7 shat the sheets in actual play there was zero chance of sliding him onto PS
If Titans would have tried he would have been claimed ... IMO
but now .... 100% chance Titans could put mw7 on PS but there is no roster need to do so. That I am aware of anyhow
mw7 was drafted as a project but his 'potential' meant Titans had to make him QB2 or let him go
I agree about a QB3 roster spot but I dont see owners asking for that. Used to be a thing back in ancient times IIRC. I seem to remember games where both QBs went down and teams were stuck with QB3 for remainder of the game
If Titans would have tried he would have been claimed ... IMO
but now .... 100% chance Titans could put mw7 on PS but there is no roster need to do so. That I am aware of anyhow
mw7 was drafted as a project but his 'potential' meant Titans had to make him QB2 or let him go
I agree about a QB3 roster spot but I dont see owners asking for that. Used to be a thing back in ancient times IIRC. I seem to remember games where both QBs went down and teams were stuck with QB3 for remainder of the game
I think the willis pick was the final
Nail in robinsons coffin. He evaluated a qb that has no business in the nfl because he had a pretty good arm. Im sure there are linebackers and tight ends that can throw a ball 65 to 70 yards but that doesnt mean you put them under center.
Nail in robinsons coffin. He evaluated a qb that has no business in the nfl because he had a pretty good arm. Im sure there are linebackers and tight ends that can throw a ball 65 to 70 yards but that doesnt mean you put them under center.
I mean someone better might be available post TC and if so thanks Mr. Dobbs leave your contact number with the receptionist
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
