I was deployed during this game but was the whistle blown as if it was incomplete?
The fumble review rule would allow a challenge and if deemed a fumble, because Miami clearly recovered, they should get the ball where recovered.
If I remember, that stood as a TD? Which meant they’d have called it a fumble on the field and allowed the runback despite a whistle?
Bunch more examples but none are exactly the same situation.
1:05 is close
1:43 is similar
2:08 is a great one (Cin vs Oak)
Another point in a couple spots though, note the 2:08 video, the bengals were given an option to take the ball where he fumbled and the whistle was blown OR replay the down.
For the 1:43 spot, no down redone either.
So the entirety of the situation is not that the play should have been redone, at least from some of these other examples.
1:05 is close
1:43 is similar
2:08 is a great one (Cin vs Oak)
Another point in a couple spots though, note the 2:08 video, the bengals were given an option to take the ball where he fumbled and the whistle was blown OR replay the down.
For the 1:43 spot, no down redone either.
So the entirety of the situation is not that the play should have been redone, at least from some of these other examples.
I can’t hear a whistle in the replay, it just looks like everyone stopped at least thinking it was incomplete.
Play was also challenged and lost for incomplete pass?
You sposta be up making breakfast.
But rub is an old favorite of a shop I worked in years ago because he’s got that woo woo!
Thass only in the morning!
Man, I lived in Oakland when this came out and they were instant celebrities.
Back when Navy internet allowed some of the original YouTube type sites, Buhne Rubb and Lil Sis we’re regulars.
nope TD stood... IIRC some officials were waiving INC others just stood there like idiots... clearly NOT a competitive play
I’m only pointing out there are some differences between that play and the play in question.
Doesn’t make it right and that one seems it could have been changed at multiple levels:
-incomplete pass,
-fumble and whistle blew (didn’t hear it)
-before any recovery, fumble and whistle blew (didn’t hear it) after recovery,
-fumble, recovered, and returned.
clearly a pass as the 'fumble' went 15 yards in the air
IIRC 'they' said something about empty hand or something about T17s hand at release...
my point was ZERO consistency
should have replayed tiger TD from last week cause they clearly blew play dead before completion. This lack of consistency gives the appearance, if not actuality, of favoritism
IIRC 'they' said something about empty hand or something about T17s hand at release...
my point was ZERO consistency
should have replayed tiger TD from last week cause they clearly blew play dead before completion. This lack of consistency gives the appearance, if not actuality, of favoritism
acutally I was wrong... they blew the play dead... should have been a like 2 yard SAC cause THAT is what they blew the whistle on... and they should have lived with that :bs: cause THAT was what they called with their too quick whistle
Wow. They really couldn’t have F’d that play up any more than they did.
Whistle should have stopped play on what was never a sack, it was a forward pass they somehow called a fumble, and then they allowed a return on what should have been a dead ball from either the incomplete pass OR the whistle.
I still didn’t hear a whistle though, but I really didn’t look for any more videos of it.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
