Guest viewing is limited

Welcome To The HFBM Boards
Hockey, Football, Baseball & MMA

Status
Not open for further replies.
RollTide said:
As usual gunny you provide a useless argument. Don't ask me how many games volek has played tell me. It's 2 clicks away.. Volek has been through 7 camps-preseasons, appeared in 24 games and started 10 games..

So we should automatically take the oldest QB on the planet and just start him? Is that your logic?
Click to expand...

Where do you pull that rubbish from?

Where did I say take the oldest QB>

24 games is not even two seasons worth of playing. How does watching for 5 other seasons make him so much more experienced?

You learn by doing.:rolleyes:
 
I just don't tust Collins with the Titans offense so early, Volek will defo start, but after the first few games, after the bye perhaps, Collins starts or maybe Young (but I don't like that idea), but that is slightly unfair on Volek, because we have got a tough opening schedule where are best hope is 2-4...

...I don't like his style of play, and I'm not sure how he will change the Titans around...he won't basically, but he's cheap...
 
Collins is god!

Career of mediocrity..

Gets signed.

Plays a few days later..

Completes 53.5% of his passes..

Becomes the god of titan present!:sad2:


You guys don't get it. He was available and relatively cheap. The addition of collins is like adding another billy volek. Based on gunny's logic we should suit up johnny unitas. More experience! Of course johnny is dead. Collins isn't quite there yet..
 
Another thing Fish is saying that ought to tell you Collins in here to be the starter..."No matter who starts against the Jets, VY is # 2...Now lets me ask ya...is either Volek or Collins gonna be a Million dollar a year # 3 ? I don't think so.
 
24 games not enough experience to play...

......according to gunny. Hmmm if you don't play how can you get experience and if you don't have experience you shouldn't play?

We are a week away from the beginning of the season and suddenly billy volek is hurting for game experience? Wow what a bomb shell!
 
Bamarron...

Think out of the box man. We are not paying some super star QB $10mm a year so we can afford to have both those guys.

Volek and collins have a collective value. If one goes down we still have the other. We don't have to force feed vince young if we don't want to. We can still play to win and not just for next season..

We normally keep three QBs right? Well there they are.
 
RollTide said:
Think out of the box man. We are not paying some super star QB $10mm a year so we can afford to have both those guys.

Volek and collins have a collective value. If one goes down we still have the other. We don't have to force feed vince young if we don't want to. We can still play to win and not just for next season..

We normally keep three QBs right? Well there they are.
Click to expand...

Certainly, at this point we are all just speculating...My point was not that by league standards a million is a lot of money for a QB...But Collins was brought here to play, and Volek will not stand by and watch himself go from #1 to #3 on the depth chart.

As for where we will get another QB...Today they're crawling from the woodwork...

If Billy want's to stay at the # 3 position (and I think that's where he ends up)
then we'll keep him. I just can't see that happening...We'll see I could be wrong...

P.S. Roll Tide
 
RollTide said:
......according to gunny. Hmmm if you don't play how can you get experience and if you don't have experience you shouldn't play?

We are a week away from the beginning of the season and suddenly billy volek is hurting for game experience? Wow what a bomb shell!
Click to expand...

Roll - I know it is your forte to take what people say and spin it any other way, maybe you were a journalist in a previous life.

But 7 years or not, Volek has start 10 games and mopped up, filled in for McNair a few other times.

And based on your logic, we could sign Ty Detmer because he has been in the league for 13 years or whatever and he will suffice.


- boy it's fun to BS your way through a topic.
 
Bamarron...crash

You think volek is gone? Well they darn well better hurry. We have a game coming up in a week!

Who in the hell would we get to replace volek in our depth chart? Nobody in this organization. Who is the quality QB that someone just cut loose? Who is the guy that can play but will be so cheap? The guy who would be ready to play sept 10th? Nobody!

The combined cap hit of volek, collins and young is no more than what the ravens are paying one steve mcnair.

What i see in you guys is this notion that this year doesn't matter anyway. Who cares if we lose 10-11 games. Right? It must be if it is ok for you that collins be our only experienced QB..

Who are these stud QBs crawling out of the woodwork? Better and cheaper than volek? That's nonsense!
 
Crash Override said:
You don't keep 3 QBs who make a lot of money.
Click to expand...


I agree...but I'm trying to remember, isn't the veteran minimum around $800,000 ? If it is then a Million isn't that much of a strech.
 
Roll...Take a pill man...none of us know what's gonna happen...I've discussed what might be. And nobody is as tired of losing as I am. I've like Billy and still do. I'm no longer sure he gives us the best chance to win....If you want to argue more go ahead...I'm done with this subject.

We'll see what happens
 
Bullcrap gunny..

How did i spin anything the wrong way? Either you don't think volek is experienced to succeed or you don't. Maybe if you just had a real opinion instead of smart asses quips you wouldn't feel like you are not understood.

Show me the post where you expressed concern about volek's lack of game experience. Show me that post gunny! Way back in march, april or may where gunny is deeply concerned about that. You were not concerned! Now mediocre kerry collins comes down the pike and volek is inadequate. Bullcrap!

If simply having more experience makes a guy better then tommy maddox should still be starting for the steelers..
 
So we should automatically take the oldest QB on the planet and just start him? Is that your logic?
Click to expand...

Based on gunny's logic we should suit up johnny unitas.
Click to expand...

and what is funny, I said that wasn't my logic, but no, little RollyPolly can't read and goes on his merry way of making crap up.

24 games is not enough experience according to gunny
Click to expand...

There are just some in a long history of you spinning BS.

FYI - 24 games (and only 10 starts) does not make you a vet is what my point was.

I dont care if Volek or Collins start, whoever gives us the best chance of winning.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top