So you agree he is infinitely better than Mariota.
He is better, I ain't blind!
This thread is about CD84 but as I read the opinions it comes back to the same thing. QB play and play calling. Tannehill gives us a better chance to move the ball thru the air but Smith is like a Murlarkey protégé. It's like one step forward and one step back. Tannehill is more accurate than Mariota but imo he's held back due to Arthur Smith's playcalling.We need a fresh creative OC who can utilize our playmakers. that's been a problem for years with this Franchise.
I feel like they have been stuck in the type of playcalling that we are getting most of the Mariota era. Regardless of HC or OC, we would end up reverting back to the same play types. Now that we are using Tannehill, that system needs to be scrapped. After the end of the season I expect to see Art go back to position coaching and we bring in a more open offensive minded OC. Atleast that is my hope.
That is my hope as well. The play calling is too predictable. It's bad enough with Vrabel making random 4th down calls. We have too much talent to be ranked near the bottom on offense.
Not love, just looking at the big picture...fun fact Aaron Rodgers and mariota had similar qbr last year....why?
That is an excellent question because Mariota wasn't even a bump on the ass of Rodgers last season. My first answer would be that proves that qbr is broken.
Davis could have tried to dive on the deep ball up the left sideline. It wasn't that bad. The endzone ball was underthrown by Tannehill though.
If he were taken 2nd round, there would be a case for benefit of the doubt...
not 5th overall tho...
Or aaron rodgers played conservative due to changes
Or changes affected his play....
Pretty sure we had one...
lets see...
2018... 62.3% 4,442 yards 25 tds 2 ints
2018... 68.9% 2,538 yards 11 tds 8 ints
I am pretty sure which stats belongs to which qb. Now, whatever point you were trying to make really falls short.
Rodgers had a 97.6 QBR and Mariota was 92.3. Given that most ratings are between 90 and 100, they aren't that similar.
This is why we are having trouble getting anything out of the receivers. Smith is doing the defense's job for them and taking them out of the play.View attachment 16602
Not sure just by that still shot, but if the WR's really ran those routes with the safeties sitting right there, it's an embarrassment to the highest degree.
The person on Twitter who posted it says that he calls this pretty often on third down.
That sucks. That play really sucks.
thats pretty but he had 5 games with ONE passing td.....hell he threw fifty times one game and couldn't get 250 yards.
I agree. Watching his route design is atrocious. I've been calling him since game 1. Dude is a jokee
How many games did your boy have only 1 td, in fact how many did he have 0 tds?
No one would ever allow a trash qb like Mariota to throw 50 times in one game.
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
