The fumble was very close.
I think the situation has been called incomplete before but also called fumble.
Looks to me that his arm was at the crescent point of pulling back and moving it forward. Not sure he had control, but definitely had the ball in his hand as he chit it forward,
Sucks the titans D had that game won I think but the offense did so poorly that they gave it away to the Jax D.
I think the situation has been called incomplete before but also called fumble.
Looks to me that his arm was at the crescent point of pulling back and moving it forward. Not sure he had control, but definitely had the ball in his hand as he chit it forward,
Sucks the titans D had that game won I think but the offense did so poorly that they gave it away to the Jax D.
we are talking about a garbage call by the refs...
you want to blame the mexican ol then go ahead... but the refs called that pass a fumble... ZERO chance its a fumble if its a rogers/mahomes/brady pass
I agree with that. If one of the media darling QBs were the QB there, it’s called incomplete.
No matter what, if many other QB/team was involved, this play would be on constant replay for the next week or longer. Because it’s Dobbs/Titans, we’ve probably heard the end of it at least from a “controversial” standpoint.
Jags YT channel puts up a video titled "we run the south"
Rofl child please
16 weeks of losing division, 1 week of having it handed to you vs PS QB picked up 2 weeks ago
But you run the division, got it
Rofl child please
16 weeks of losing division, 1 week of having it handed to you vs PS QB picked up 2 weeks ago
But you run the division, got it
Agreed. Can't be mad at it.
I just hate how the commentators say "it's the right thing to just call it a fumble and let it play out". Calls only get overturned if the evidence is IRREFUTABLE. Most of the time it just stands. So no, don't just call it a fumble.
Yeah I'm not a big fan of just letting it play out incase it is a fumble. Here it was the right call but I'd you think it's incomplete you gotta call it dead.
While I somewhat agree with the perspective that the media darling get a lot more attention in such things ... By rule, the ball was out of his hand and he pushed it forward. Mistake by Dobbs not seeing the pressure coming.
Overall....I think Dobbs did a hell of a job in his 2 starts. Much better than Willis will ever be from what we have seen of him.
I honestly can't say that Tannehill would have faired any better under the circumstances..so I really give it to Dobbs for coming in and giving his all.
It would have been a Cinderella story for Dobbs to come in and get to the playoffs under the circumstances. Half the team is on IR. I dont even know who was playing on the OLine. The odds have been stacked against the Titans for most of the season...last year they overcame the odds...this year is what last year should have been.
By rule, it was definitely a fumble. The ball popped went forward 10 yards because of the way Dobbs got hit. But let’s be for real, if it were Maholmes, Allen, or Brady, that play would have been whistled dead. I mean, ask yourself what’s more exciting for other NFL fans, watching Jacksonville continue to be the Cinderella story on their loud home turf and Trevor Lawrence in the playoffs or Josh Dobbs in the playoffs.
To me, it was pretty clear that it was a fumble even in real time. He "pushed" it forward. The right thing to do is call it a fumble and then review it because it can be overturned. If you call it a pass, it stand as a pass no matter what.
Again, I agree that the top QBs probably get a little more cushion on such calls.
But, I think Dobbs and the Titans making the playoffs would be a bigger story line. Coming off a big losing streak to win the division with a QB that has been around for 2 weeks is compelling vs a team that was on a hot streak, imo.
We were on a hot mess streak.
F THE BIASED COMMENTATORS!!!!!!!
I
Insanity
I mean, that’s Daly’s side of the line. He should have expected a guy running free like every other play.
I was looking at those stats last night actually; we scored 20 or more points only 6 times all season, and two of those were in losing efforts. Pathetic. Fire No O Tdd Dwning.
You wouldn't DARE!?!?!
- Status
- Not open for further replies.
